Africa’s position on United Security Council reforms and its implications on Africa’s peace and security aspirations.
Abstract
The overall objective of this study is to interrogate the correlation between Africa‟s call for
reforms and the Council‟s effectiveness in responding to peace and security challenges on the
continent. To unpack this objective the study also examined the Africa‟s peace and security
aspirations, historical relations between the Council and Africa, the AU reform proposal and
its implications on Africa‟s peace and security challenges. The study is based on the case
study of Africa. The study was grounded in qualitative research in which the researcher
utilised purposive sampling to select knowledgeable and experienced participants for in-depth
interviews. Documentary research was also utilised to collect secondary data. Thematic
analysis and Content analysis were also used to analyse both primary and secondary data
respectively. Elements of Collective Security, Multilateralism, Regional Security Complex
Theory and Constructivism shaped the framework for analysis for this study. The study
established that the AU aspires to have a secure and peaceful continent by 2063. Africa
believes that only a reformed Council will effectively contribute to this end. The study also
established that although the intended reform will enhance the Council lost legitimacy, this
would not automatically contribute to the Council‟s efficacy due to divisions among African
countries on the basis of colonial history and sub-regional blocs, regional interests versus
national interests and the global geopolitical realities that will continue to shape global peace
projects. The study concludes that there is need to balance the moral argument for equitable
geographical representation and global power realities which seems to be the stringboard of
state action in international system. The study recommends that AU should embrace global
power polities and realities, establish written text based negotiations on the criteria for
selecting Africa representatives in the Security Council and foster continental unity among
African Countries as this would enables the AU to strategically position itself beyond the
ideal architectural framework of the Security Council
Additional Citation Information
Mutemachani, D. (2017). Africa’s position on United Security Council reforms and its implications on Africa’s peace and security aspirations. [Unpublished masters thesis]. University of Zimbabwe.Publisher
University of Zimbabwe
Subject
Reforms and the CouncilAfrica’s peace and security challenges
Elements of Collective Security
Regional Security Complex Theory
Intergovernmental Negotiations
United Nations Security Council
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Reinforcement of military security in Africa: tha case of AFRICOM
Nyamukomba, Rudo (University of Zimbabwe, 2015-03)The current military security situation in Africa is shaped by a number of factors which include the fight against terrorism, coups and intrastate conflicts. Terrorism is a security threat to Africa and is growing at an ... -
Africa’s position on United Security Council reforms and its implications on Africa’s peace and security aspirations.
Mutemachani, Deelixirnirvan (University of Zimbabwe, 2017-03)The overall objective of this study is to interrogate the correlation between Africa's call for reforms and the Council's effectiveness in responding to peace and security challenges on the continent. To unpack this ... -
Security sector reform: State security and human security relations in Zimbabwe - the case of Zimbabwe Defence Forces (ZDF) 1980-2008
Bangidza, Lucky Bassie (2017-03)This thesis examined the origins, concepts and practices of the security sector reform (SSR), as the independent variable, using state security (SS) and human security (SS) as the dependent variables for analysis. The ...